Overemphasis on narrow, strictly GDP-based figures as a primary tool in evaluating societal progress has often been criticized. Can this single criterion provide a reliable picture of the true state of affairs and progress at regional level?
If the GDP has shown itself to be an insufficient indicator in the accurate measurement of the true progress of a society in terms of its well-being, quality of life and sustainable development, what should now supersede it?
The IDeal Index as new instrument helping better orientation of regional economic development policies.
Paola Ghillani & Friends Ltd has been developing the IDeal Index at the initiative of the Canton de Fribourg and his State counsellor, Beat Vonlanthen.
The requirements set for the elaboration of the IDeal Index were:
– remain synthetic, as to facilitate communication and interpretation;
– offer in parallel more detailed indications on different parameters, to allow the orientation of regional development policies;
– be sufficiently broad to cover the three pillars of sustainable development (environmental, social and economic) while also taking into account the well-being and overall satisfaction of the population;
– allow comparison between regions in Europe, and also that can be extended to the world;
– permit to track the progress over a given time frame, through periodic re-computations of indicator values;
– take into account existing initiatives underway in different countries and reflecting local realities;
– be driven by publicly available data, as to reduce the cost of its implementation.
The IDeal Index indicator developed by Paola Ghillani & Friends Ltd, meets these requirements along the lines of current indicators suggested as alternatives or complements to the GDP.
Its name, the “IDeal Index” is intended to show that this indicator is an ideal instrument at regional level, not only to evaluate real progress but also to influence or inspire politicians in their policy development, and citizens in their daily life choices. In addition, the enclosed phrase “I deal” also carries the idea of “I am in charge, I’m giving the cards, I am responsible, I participate in the sustainable development of my region.” Moreover, the decision to write the word “IDeal” with the twin capitals “ID” also shows a distinct intent to highlight that the identity (ID) of a region is involved, a kind of passport to open doors—through a better quality of life, better management of resources, finances, economic development, among others issues—toward a sustainable regional development.
As a result, the IDeal Index is a synthetic indicator made of twelve parameters divided into four categories: life expectancy, perceived satisfaction over one’s quality of life, socio-economic parameters as well as environmental parameters. These parameters are then integrated into a straightforward formula from which a comprehensive and comprehensible score can be obtained, for use by politicians and voters/citizens of the general public.
IDeal Index in the world
The ultimate goal of regions calculating the value of their IDeal Index is to promote, for their citizens, a satisfactory life in balance with the natural and socio-economical environment.
How do regions reach this goal?
They first have to know how well they perform compared to an ideal state.
This is given by the value of the IDeal Index. The higher the value is, the better the region performs.
Then they have to know where to start to increase this value.
The IDeal Index is composed of a limited number of parameters. They can be improved by political measures, but many parameters need also participation from the citizens.
The parameters include aspects of employment, health and education, management of the natural environment and biodiversity,
waste management, recycling, water and energy savings, without forgetting economical aspects.
By comparing the values of these parameters between different regions, it becomes possible to see which components need to be addressed with priority. The continuous collection of data on these parameters allows monitoring of the progresses achieved. These data are then used to calculate the next annual value of the IDeal Index
For example, the canton of Fribourg decided to conduct a campaign on energy savings and is communicating every month the results on a webpage:
http://off-fr.ch/fr-fr/challenge
These results will be used to calculate the value of the IDeal Index of Fribourg in 2015
Joseph Stiglitz, in Challenges, 27 August 2009“The objective of growth is to improve our quality of life; that of green growth, to improve our quality of life. The debate on growth-versus-environment is therefore a false dichotomy.”
Beat Vonlanthen, Minister of Economic Affairs, Canton of Fribourg“Welcome to this extraordinary circle of dynamic, innovative regions where quality of life is a top priority!”
Margaret Mead, Anthropologist”Don’t ever think that a small group of conscious and dedicated people aren’t able to change the world. In fact this is the way it always happens!”
Enrico Giovannini,”A professor of economic statistics at the University of Rome and a former Istat president, quips that non-statisticians often suggest that measuring happiness and well-being is a tricky task. His response: Have you ever tried to measure GDP?”
Stop accepting GDP, i.e. growth and productivity as an objective for measuring progress and well being Change mindset and make a donation to the IDeal Index.
As a not-for-profit project, we are developing the IDeal Index. If each conscious citizen reading this would give 5 EURO or 5 CHF or more, the needs for the IDeal Index further development for the year to come would be covered. And we would come together a step closer to a societal mindset change for a better life on our planet.
Contribute to improve the state of the world, starting by your region.
» Act to be IDeal ! »
Payment order to:
Zürcher Kantonalbank, Postfach, 8010 Zurich
Rubrique: IDEAL INDEX
Account No: 1100-5903.353
SWIFT/BIC: ZKBKCH2280A
IBAN: CH70 0070 0110 0059 0335 3
Would you need help to donate,
please send us an email at: info@idealindex.org
Become an active contributor of the IDeal Index, an alternative to GDP for citizens who care about well-being and true progress in their region.
Thanks to the IDeal Index help us to influence politicians and citizen’s behaviour, so that we can all live a sustainable and satisfied life in our respective regions and, consequently, in the whole world!
Your donation will allow to identify which factors of quality of life and sustainable development most urgently need improvement in your own region.
How does it work?
IDeal Index measures the performance of a region towards offering the chance to a satisfying life for its inhabitants. IDeal Index is a novel alternative to GDP.
IDeal Index is the result of 5 years of research and experimentation on existing rising „beyond GDP“ initiatives. We’ve kept only the best from all those initiatives in order to develop the IDeal Index.
What is the effect of your donation?
Example: Energy consumption is too high in the region of Fribourg. As a consequence the government has launched the OFF campaign, in order to inspire citizen and enterprises to reduce their energy consumption with smart ideas.
The objectives of this website go beyond informing about the IDeal Index, it is also about supporting and ensuring the further development of the IDeal Index for at least 150 regions during 3 years (2014-2016). So, please support us! Your support is decisive and will allow to:
Guarantee the conformity of the IDeal Index with regard to the OECD standards for aggregated indicators (see attachment).
Ensure the data collection necessary for the computing of the IDeal Index calculation in an harmonized manner and over several years; and in parallel develop a smart platform, a web-based database allowing an efficient data collection and an easy data computing. The idea being to be as user-friendly as possible for the regions member and non-member of the EU in integrating their data, and in order to get a comprehensive output of the benchmark for politicians and citizens.
And overall, sensibilise and influence, you, citizen of your region, in your behaviour, and thus inspire your politicians in their policy orientation towards more sustainability and life satisfaction.
The IDeal Index formula measures the genuine progress and well-being of the regions thanks to a one and only indicator, which supersedes GDP, considering not only economical aspects, but societal and environmental aspects as well.
Co-developer of the IDeal Index
PhD, Expert in Sustainability & Statistics
Head of the statistical service
Canton of Fribourg
Former Head of
Statistics
West Sweden
Senior Planning Officer, the Unit of Strategy,
Vaasa, West Finland
participating to the IDeal Index 1st pilot Fribourg 2013
Part 1 IDeal Index Formula for regions by Paola Ghillani
Part 2 IDeal Index Parameters for regions by Paola Ghillani
Part 3 IDeal Index Ranking/Results for Regions by Paola Ghillani
IDeal Index Political Report ARE
Communiqué de presse, Fribourg 2013-05-21
Swiss Eco Leaders Day 2013-03-14 (français)
Tribune de Genève 2013-05-24 (français)
Cleantech ALPS 2013-05-29 (français)
Are you ready to shape the future of your region?
Would you be thrilled to get the opportunity to improve the quality of life and well-being in your region?
If you answer is YES, then you definitely already “are IDeal”!
(But, maybe, don’t know it yet?)
Contribute to improve the state of the world, once, every year, every month or even every day!
Send a payment order to:
Zürcher Kantonalbank, Postfach, 8010 Zurich
Rubrique: IDEAL INDEX
Account No: 1100-5903.353
SWIFT/BIC: ZKBKCH2280A
IBAN: CH70 0070 0110 0059 0335 3
« Act to be IDeal ! »